The Badge of Honour for your Career?

The ‘holy grail’ of research seems to be being published in the big shooters, Nature and Science. How does being published in these journals affect your career and how exactly are they better than the many other journals out there?

Papers from less well known journals have also gained huge media coverage such as the recent Alzheimer’s ‘break-though’, this shows that not only nature stories are worth reporting

It’s known that up to 90% of papers submitted to Nature are rejected, is this because they are so selective, that so many people apply craving the prestige or both?

Looking into the topic I’m not the only one thinking about these questions Steven Curry a structural biology professor at ICL also broaches this in his blog Reciprocal Science and it was also a point of debate for this week’s Natures Podcast.

Getting published in these ‘Impact journals’ often leads to better opportunities for grants and funding for an academic, not to mention the doors it opens for a PhD student starting a career. However does this present an unfair advantage against scientists published in less high-status journals?

Impact factors are often a consideration when judging a study as well as topicality which may slant the scales in favour of one group, even if the science behind there results isn’t as solid. This has been discussed by Professor Seglen in 1997 showing that this issue has been lingering for a while.

I suspect there will always be the top dogs of journals.


About juliarosencl

I’m Julia Rose Humes and my main area of interest is the biochemistry of brains. Give me an intracellular pathway that leads to cell death in neurons or a drug that can affect how brain cells respond and I’m your girl. I don’t pretend to be an expert on anything but I am constantly amazed by scientific research and discoveries, and that’s my reason for wanting to be part of this blog. I hope that my career path will lead down the rabbit hole into a laboratory working on neurodegeneration but I intend keep up the hobby of scientific writing as much as I can. Science can be scary when your first starting out or don’t have a scientific background. I remember trying to read a journal article in the first few weeks of my undergraduate degree and even the title gave me a headache. If I can be any help in explaining the science behind the news or just present the intriguing science that hasn’t made it onto the TV, my job will be done.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to The Badge of Honour for your Career?

  1. indianamurphy says:

    This is interesting but I think you have a spelling mistake in yout title. I think you mean your career not you career.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s